tobecited vs Otterly.ai
Otterly.ai starts at $29 a month, and Claude and Gemini are not in that price — both are paid add-ons. The four assistants tobecited checks on every paid plan cost $67 a month there, against $19 here. Otterly does track more buyer questions on its entry plan: 15 against our 8.
Where these numbers come from
Otterly figures were read from its own pricing page on August 28, 2026. Ours are printed from the plan catalogue this site runs on — the same file the billing system enforces — so the number in this table and the number on your invoice cannot drift apart. A dash means the vendor does not publish that figure.
| Compared on | tobecited Pro — $19/mo | Otterly Lite — $29/mo |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | $19 (€17) | $29, or $25 paid annually |
| Assistants included at that price | All 4: ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity — on every paid plan | ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot |
| Price for the four assistants we check | $19 — nothing to add | $67 — Lite $29 + Claude add-on $29 + Gemini add-on $9 |
| Buyer questions per run | 8 | 15ahead of us |
| Answers per month at that price | 128 — 8 questions × 4 assistants × 4 weekly runs | — |
| Free check without a card | Yes — 3 questions × 3 assistants = 9 answers, plus a check of the answers about your brand | No free tier |
| Competitors tracked by name | 3 on Pro, 5 on Max | — |
| What to fix on your site | Yes — a work order: crawler access, page text, titles, FAQ blocks, Organization markup | No — monitoring only |
| Biggest published plan | Max $59 (€53) — 3 sites, 384 answers/mo | Premium $489 — 400 questions. Enterprise from $1,000ahead of us |
Cells marked "ahead of us" are the ones where the other tool wins.
What $29 covers, and what Claude and Gemini cost on top
Otterly Lite at $29 a month covers ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Copilot, with 15 tracked questions. Claude is a paid add-on: $29 on Lite, $109 on Standard, $439 on Premium. Gemini and Google AI Mode are further add-ons, priced between $9 and $149 depending on the plan.
So the panel this site runs — ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity — costs $29 + $29 + $9 = $67 a month at Otterly entry level. That is the one number worth taking away from this page. It is not a discount argument: it is the same four assistants, priced two ways.
Annual billing takes 15% off the plans themselves — $25, $160 and $422 for Lite, Standard and Premium. The add-on prices quoted above are the monthly ones.
Why the assistant list decides more than the question count
A tracked question is worth what the assistant answering it is worth to you. If your buyers ask Claude and the tool does not check Claude, then 15 questions across the assistants it does check will never show you that gap. It will show a clean report and a blind spot in the same picture.
tobecited runs one panel for every paid run: ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity. It is not a display option you switch on — it is how the audit is built, which is also why we cannot sell you Copilot or Google AI Overviews coverage. Those surfaces are not in our panel at all. The free check asks three of the four, without Claude.
The trade is visible in the table: our entry plan asks 8 questions where Otterly Lite asks 15, and answers all of them on four assistants where Lite answers them on four different ones.
What each tool does after the report
Otterly is a monitoring product. It shows where you are named and where you are not, and that is where it stops — the work of changing anything is yours.
tobecited writes the work order: which AI crawlers your site turns away, which facts are missing from the visible text, what each title and FAQ block lacks against the questions the assistants were actually asked, and ready Organization markup. You or your developer make the changes; we do not deploy anything to your site.
We are careful about what we claim for that work. Letting crawlers in and stating facts in the page text are what allow an assistant to read and quote you at all; that is a precondition, not a promise. We do not sell llms.txt or schema markup as a way to get cited, because measurements have found no such effect.
Where Otterly is ahead
Question volume, and it is not close at the top of the range. Otterly Lite tracks 15 questions to our 8, Premium tracks 400 for $489, and there is an Enterprise tier above that. If you need breadth of questions on one brand more than breadth of assistants, Otterly gives you more of it per dollar at every level.
Coverage we simply do not have: Otterly monitors Copilot and Google AI Overviews. We check neither, and no add-on on our side fixes that. If Microsoft or Google AI Overviews is where your buyers are, Otterly sees a surface we are blind to.
Otterly has also been in the market longer and is named in AI answers about this category more often than we are — including in answers to questions about us. We know because we run the same audit on our own domain that we sell.
Check your own site before you pick a tool
No card. 3 assistants in the free check, 4 on paid runs. The report is yours whether you buy anything or not.
What this comparison is not
- This is not a claim that Otterly is a weaker product. It monitors two surfaces we do not touch at all — Copilot and Google AI Overviews — and it tracks more questions on every plan than we do.
- We are not promising that ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Perplexity will start recommending you. We measure what they answer today and hand you the changes worth making.
- These prices are a snapshot, not a live feed. Otterly figures were read from its pricing page on August 28, 2026 and can change without notice.
- Only published plans are compared. Enterprise pricing on either side is negotiated per customer and is not in this table.
Questions buyers ask before switching
- How much does Otterly.ai cost with Claude and Gemini included?
- $67 a month at entry level: Lite at $29, the Claude add-on at $29 and the Gemini add-on at $9. Higher up the range the Claude add-on is $109 on Standard and $439 on Premium. Prices read from Otterly's pricing page on August 28, 2026.
- Does Otterly.ai have a free plan?
- No free tier as of August 28, 2026. tobecited runs a free check with no card: 3 buyer questions, 3 assistants, 9 answers, plus what those assistants say about your brand, checked against your own site.
- Which tool tracks more buyer questions?
- Otterly. Its $29 Lite plan tracks 15 questions, our $19 Pro plan tracks 8, and Otterly Premium goes to 400. If question count is what you are buying, Otterly gives you more of it.
- Which assistants does tobecited check that Otterly charges extra for?
- Claude and Gemini. Both are in every paid tobecited run at no extra cost. At Otterly both are add-ons billed on top of the plan price, at $29 and $9 respectively on the Lite tier.
- Can I move my Otterly history into tobecited?
- No. No tool in this category imports another one’s answer history, and a series stitched together from two different question sets and two different methods would not be comparable anyway. Start a fresh series here and keep the old one as reference.
- Which one suits an agency better?
- It depends on which way your work scales. Otterly scales by questions on a single brand. tobecited Max monitors 3 sites for $59 a month with 5 named competitors each. Count sites if you run many small clients; count questions if you run one large brand deeply.